Sunset Key Cottages, Key WestSunset Key Cottages in Key West, United States has a corrected score of 3.3 ± 0.6 (thin evidence, no platform scores), ranked 16 of 40 hotels we score in Key West. Its platform ratings, normalised to 0-5, average 4.6 before correction. Rooms from about $1,090 a night (cached, not a live quote).Sunset Key Cottages is a resort on a private 27-acre island off the coast of Key West, Florida, reached by a short ferry ride. Accommodation is in one- to four-bedroom cottages set among tropical gardens, with a private beach, spa, swimming pool, gym and an on-site restaurant offering waterfront dining and ocean views. Kitchens, room service, valet parking and pet-friendly policies add to the practicalities, and children are welcome. Rates start at $1,090 per night, so it suits families or groups seeking an exclusive island stay with plenty of space rather than travellers on a budget. Guest reviews are strong at 9.2, though some cottages are less modern than others, and windy weather can limit beach time.What stands out

Private island with exclusive beach

Spacious one to four bedroom cottages

Waterfront dining and full spa

Attentive staff, daily pastry delivery

Watch out for

Cottage condition varies between units

Windy weather can limit beach time

Better-scored in Key West

The Capitana, Key West: 4.0 ± 0.3 (fair evidence, 2 of 4 platforms), from $241 a night. The Capitana is a waterfront boutique hotel in Key West, Florida, set on the bay with broad water views from its rooms and balconies.

Little Palm Island, Key West: 3.8 ± 0.4 (thin evidence, 1 of 4 platforms), from $2,379 a night. Little Palm Island Resort & Spa occupies its own island off Little Torch Key in the Florida Keys, reached only by boat.

Hyatt Vacation Club At Beach House Key W, Key West: 3.7 ± 0.2 (solid evidence, 3 of 4 platforms), from $422 a night. Hyatt Vacation Club At Beach House Key W is a condominium-style resort located on the northeast side of Key West along the Overseas Highway.