The Pridwin Hotel And Cottages in Shelter Island, United States has a corrected score of 3.4 ± 0.6 (thin evidence, no platform scores), ranked 1 of 2 hotels we score in Shelter Island. Its platform ratings, normalised to 0-5, average 4.6 before correction.
The Pridwin Hotel and Cottages is a long-established waterfront resort on Shelter Island, New York, open since 1927. It is the island's largest hotel, with 33 rooms in the main building plus 16 private cottages, making 49 accommodations in all. The property sits along Crescent Beach, with views over the ocean. Facilities include a swimming pool, a tennis court, room service and an all-American restaurant, and the hotel welcomes families with children. It also caters for weddings, corporate retreats and holiday getaways. Guests praise the food, the staff and the range of activities on offer, from sailing to paddleboarding. Bear in mind that reaching Shelter Island requires a ferry, so the location is deliberately quiet rather than convenient.
All hotels in Shelter Island, ranked
How the scores work · Statistics · Guides · API · llms.txt
No hotel can pay for placement or a better score. Scores rebuilt 2026-10-02.