Gurneys Montauk, MontaukGurneys Montauk in Montauk, United States has a corrected score of 2.8 ± 0.3 (fair evidence, 2 of 4 platforms), ranked 6 of 6 hotels we score in Montauk. Its platform ratings, normalised to 0-5, average 2.7 before correction: Booking.com 2.5, Tripadvisor 3.0.Gurneys Montauk is a beachfront resort situated on Old Montauk Highway in Montauk. The property consists of 158 rooms, suites, and cottages that face the ocean. Guests can access a seawater spa, a gym, and a swimming pool. On-site dining is available alongside various wellness services such as massages and a sauna. The hotel accommodates families and allows pets. While the location provides direct beach access and views, recent guest feedback indicates that the service standards and value for money do not always meet the high price points charged.What stands out

Direct beachfront access

On-site seawater spa

Various room types including cottages

Pet friendly facilities

Watch out for

Low value for money

Inconsistent staff training

Better-scored in Montauk

Montauk Yacht Club, Montauk: 3.9 ± 0.3 (fair evidence, 2 of 4 platforms), from $300 a night. Montauk Yacht Club is a waterfront resort and marina situated on 16 acres along Lake Montauk.

Hotel Corduroy, Montauk: 3.5 ± 0.4 (thin evidence, 1 of 4 platforms), from $251 a night. Hotel Corduroy is a new three-star boutique hotel in the Culloden Shores area of Montauk, due to open in spring 2026.

Hero Beach Club, Montauk: 3.3 ± 0.6 (thin evidence, no platform scores), from $381 a night. Hero Beach Club is a boutique hotel in Montauk, a short walk from the beach.