Best hotels in Montauk, ranked by corrected score

Best hotels in Montauk, ranked by corrected scoreThe best-scored hotel in Montauk is Montauk Yacht Club: 3.9 ± 0.3 (fair evidence, 2 of 4 platforms) on our corrected 0-5 score, from $300 a night. Next are Hotel Corduroy (3.5) and Hero Beach Club (3.3). We score 6 hotels in Montauk, United States. Their platform ratings (normalised to 0-5) average 3.7; after correction the average is 3.3, and 0 rest on solid evidence.Best hotels in Montauk, ranked

Montauk Yacht Club, Montauk: 3.9 ± 0.3 (fair evidence, 2 of 4 platforms), from $300 a night. Montauk Yacht Club is a waterfront resort and marina situated on 16 acres along Lake Montauk.

Hotel Corduroy, Montauk: 3.5 ± 0.4 (thin evidence, 1 of 4 platforms), from $251 a night. Hotel Corduroy is a new three-star boutique hotel in the Culloden Shores area of Montauk, due to open in spring 2026.

Hero Beach Club, Montauk: 3.3 ± 0.6 (thin evidence, no platform scores), from $381 a night. Hero Beach Club is a boutique hotel in Montauk, a short walk from the beach.

Atlantic Terrace Montauk Hotel, Montauk: 3.2 ± 0.2 (fair evidence, 2 of 4 platforms), from $462 a night. Atlantic Terrace Montauk Hotel, now operating as Marram Montauk, is an oceanfront resort situated among the sand dunes in Montauk.

Ruschmeyers Montauk, Montauk: 3.2 ± 0.6 (thin evidence, no platform scores). Ruschmeyers Montauk is a 19-cabin hotel on the northwestern edge of Fort Pond in Montauk, New York, about a nine-minute walk from Navy Road Beach.

Gurneys Montauk, Montauk: 2.8 ± 0.3 (fair evidence, 2 of 4 platforms). Gurneys Montauk is a beachfront resort situated on Old Montauk Highway in Montauk.