Sunset Beach in Shelter Island, United States has a corrected score of 2.3 ± 0.4 (thin evidence, 1 of 4 platforms), ranked 2 of 2 hotels we score in Shelter Island. Its platform ratings, normalised to 0-5, average 1.5 before correction: Tripadvisor 1.5.
Sunset Beach is a seasonal four-star boutique hotel located on Crescent Beach in Shelter Island. Owned by André Balazs, the property features between 20 and 37 rooms designed with a simple beach shack aesthetic and European influence. Guests stay in rooms with private balconies overlooking the ocean and Peconic Bay. On-site facilities include a restaurant, bar, boutique, and massage services. The hotel accommodates families and pets, and provides air conditioning and parking. Because it operates on a seasonal basis, it is not available year-round. The setting is quiet with minimal traffic, making it suitable for those seeking a relaxed coastal atmosphere.
All hotels in Shelter Island, ranked
How the scores work · Statistics · Guides · API · llms.txt
No hotel can pay for placement or a better score. Scores rebuilt 2026-10-02.